The Watcher stood tall in my household room, bald and berobed, nestled amongst my youngsters’ toys, sleeping cats and TV. I used to be being requested to assist save the multiverse! So started Marvel and ILM Interactive’s What If…? on the Apple Imaginative and prescient Professional. Just like the Disney+ sequence and comics of the identical identify, this interactive expertise recontextualizes Marvel’s characters in a wide range of intriguing methods — what if the Allies by no means received World Battle 2 and the Captain America experiment was a failure, for instance.
What If…? has all the time been a enjoyable idea, however can it really be remodeled right into a worthwhile augmented actuality showpiece? Effectively, sure and no — a minimum of, based mostly on the hour I spent with it on the Apple Imaginative and prescient Professional.
Earlier than I dive into main criticisms, I am going to say up entrance that What If…? is clearly an experiment, so tough edges are to be anticipated. I give Marvel and ILM Interactive credit score for making it utterly free for Imaginative and prescient Professional customers and for taking a large swing at a platform with out many customers. The whole expertise additionally appears splendidly detailed, due to the mixture of Marvel and ILM’s immersive environments and character animation, in addition to the sheer energy of the Imaginative and prescient Professional’s M2 processor. It is the closest you will get to dwelling inside a comic book.
Marvel has already dabbled in digital actuality with Iron Man for the PSVR and Quest, in addition to Marvel Powers United VR, however What If…? is an try to perform one thing much more immersive: What should you might work together with superheroes proper in your house? Largely, although, I discovered myself asking “What if this experience was actually fun to play?”
You are positioned within the position of a mystical apprentice, wielding powers just like Physician Unusual. Initially you may maintain up a fist to manifest a defend, or look in direction of objects to make use of telekinesis. However you ultimately achieve the flexibility to shoot mystical blasts and entice enemies. All of it sounds extremely cool in idea, however in observe it felt worse than the first-gen VR video games I performed a decade in the past.
Largely, that is as a result of What If…? depends in your fingers for every little thing. The Imaginative and prescient Professional does not have a devoted VR controller just like the Oculus Quest or HTC Vive, which provide instantaneous button inputs and might be tracked by way of IR sensors. As a substitute, you need to wait a fraction of a second for Apple’s headset to acknowledge your fingers and decide what you are attempting to do. Consequently, What If…? feels extra such as you’re sitting by way of a Marvel theme park trip, shifting from one state of affairs to the following with out a lot energetic participation. It is a poor approach to make you are feeling like a multiverse-hopping adventurer.
On the very least, What If…? exhibits off what Marvel might do if it targeted extra on the Imaginative and prescient Professional and no matter Oculus has cooking subsequent. Like a campy 3D movie, the sport wastes no time attempting to blow you away with its core gimmick. It kicks off with a remixed Marvel intro montage in 2D, floating in entrance of you in augmented actuality. As Michael Giacchino’s iconic rating crescendoes, you are instantly surrounded by clips of the sequence drifting in from outdoors your subject of view. It is a transient second, nevertheless it’s the type of factor that would not be as impactful in a conventional VR headset, the place you are immersed in an alternate actuality from the beginning.
The expertise really begins with the aforementioned Watcher — one among Marvel’s cosmic beings who observe its many universes — roping you in for an journey. You realize the drill: Discover all the Infinity Stones and cease whoever is attempting to destroy all recognized creation. Children’ stuff. Alongside the way in which, you will run into alternate-universe variations of acquainted characters: Thor’s sister Hela, who solely desires to save lots of her beloved large wolf Fenris; a model of Steve Rogers who appears eerily just like the Crimson Cranium; and a extra sympathetic Thanos.
What If…? strikes between digital environments that totally immerse you within the motion and augmented actuality situations, the place The Watcher and some companions putter round your room. You are able to do the identical, generally, however inside the VR segments, the sport expects you to remain nonetheless. You may additionally must click on by way of Imaginative and prescient Professional pop-ups about being aware of your environment earlier than each VR scene — a essential evil for individuals unfamiliar with VR, but additionally one thing that kills immersion since it is not built-in into the sport.
Regardless of my points with the gameplay, I finally had a decently entertaining hour with What If…? It was a fast Marvel repair in a time the place I’ve grown uninterested in the onslaught of Disney+ MCU exhibits. I simply can’t assist however want it had been extra enjoyable to play. I am hoping this launch helps Marvel and ILM Interactive get higher at constructing AR and VR experiences. And for Apple, it is a clear signal that some type of Imaginative and prescient Professional controller can be useful down the road.
